Under Threat: Potential Competition, Litigation and the Private Value of Patent Protection
نویسنده
چکیده
This paper investigates the effect of the threat and occurrence of patent litigation on the private value of patent protection. Potential challenges are introduced into a renewal model as a factor in patentee decisions as to whether a patent is worth maintaining. The model yields testable predictions about renewal probabilities. Data for post WWII German patents support the hypothesis that the need to defend patent rights influences patentee behaviour. The paper concludes with a discussion of how this factor may be incorporated in patent value estimations and what the results imply for the interpretation of patent data.
منابع مشابه
Patent Litigation when Innovation is Cumulative
This paper studies the effect of litigation as a way to enforce patents when firms hold private information. Patent protection granted by courts affect the entry, settlement and litigation decisions of future innovations. The model is broadly consistent with recent empirical evidence. We show that higher protection might be detrimental to the patentholder since it reduces entry of infringers th...
متن کاملThreats to sue and cost divisibility under asymmetric information
The early literature on litigation and settlement assumed that a plaintiff’s threat to litigate is credible only when her litigation value—the difference between the expected judgment and her litigation costs—is positive. More recently, however, Bebchuk (1996) has suggested that even if the plaintiff’s litigation value is negative, divisibility of her litigation costs may render credibility to ...
متن کاملThe Patent System and Competition A Statement to the Federal Trade Commission/ Department of Justice Hearings on Competition and Intellectual Property Law and Policy in the Knowledge-Based Economy
The U.S. patent system has undergone a profound shift over the past two decades. The strength of patent protection has been dramatically bolstered, and both large and small firms are devoting considerably more effort to seeking patent protection and defending their patents in the courts. Many in the patent community—U.S. Patent and Trademark Office officials, the patent bar, and corporate paten...
متن کاملInjunctive and Reverse Settlements in Competition-Blocking Litigation (with Keith N. Hylton)
We distinguish standard settlements, in which the status quo is preserved, and injunctive settlements, which prohibit the defendant’s activity. The reverse (payment) settlement is a special type of injunctive settlement. We examine the divergence between private and social incentives to settle and policies that would minimize socially undesirable injunctive and reverse settlements (e.g., bannin...
متن کاملThe fuzzy value of patent litigation under imprecise information
The vague notion of "probabilistic patents" is formalized through a model which combines real option theory and a fuzzy methodology. The imprecise estimates the patent holder possesses about her future profits, the validity and scope of the patent, the litigation costs, the court's decision etc. under a regime of imperfect enforcement of property rights are specified modelling uncertainty with ...
متن کامل